The short answer: a tracker can count your hours, and the hours are what sleep debt is made of. Sleep debt is the sleep you needed minus the sleep you got, added up over several nights. No device measures that directly. A tracker estimates how long you slept, and something has to subtract that from a sleep need and keep the running total.
Of the three trackers on this page, one does that subtraction for you. Oura shows a Sleep Debt figure against a sleep need it learns from your own nights. Apple Watch and the Withings Sleep Analyzer show how long you slept and give the night a score, but neither shows a debt. For those two, the calculator does the arithmetic, and the rest of this page shows how.
You do not need a tracker to work out your sleep debt. A week of honest bedtimes and wake times is enough. What a tracker saves you is the remembering, and it is usually better than memory at telling time asleep from time in bed.
What a tracker actually measures
Every consumer tracker works the same way underneath. It watches movement and heart rate, and sometimes breathing, and infers from those whether you are asleep. A sleep lab does something different: polysomnography reads brain activity directly, and that is still the reference every device is tested against.
Total sleep time is the number trackers do reasonably well. In a 2021 study in Sleep, Chinoy and colleagues tested seven consumer devices against lab recordings. They were good at spotting sleep and much weaker at spotting wakefulness: lying still and awake tends to be counted as asleep, so a tracker is more likely to flatter your night than to undersell it. None of the three devices on this page were in that study, but they work on the same principles.
Sleep stages are estimates, and weaker ones. The same study found stage classification inconsistent between devices, and worse on nights of poor or broken sleep. Deep, light and REM figures are interesting to look at. They are not something to manage your evening around.
For sleep debt, duration is the useful number. The research behind the idea of sleep debt, including the experiment that held people to six hours a night for two weeks, is about hours of sleep, not stages. So when you read a tracker for this purpose, look for time asleep and ignore the rest.
How each one shows your sleep
Oura Ring shows a nightly Sleep Score, and for members a Sleep Need (worked out from your typical sleep over the past 90 days) and a Sleep Debt in hours, calculated over the past two weeks with more weight on recent nights. Oura groups it as none, low (under two hours), moderate (two to five) or high (over five). It needs a Gen3 ring or later and an active membership. More on Oura and sleep debt.
Apple Watch shows time asleep, estimated stages (Awake, REM, Core and Deep), and a Sleep Score out of 100: up to 50 points for duration, 30 for bedtime consistency and 20 for interruptions. You set a sleep goal in the Health app on iPhone, but there is no running debt. More on Apple Watch and sleep debt.
Withings Sleep Analyzer is a mat that goes under the mattress. It records sleep duration, how long you took to fall asleep and to get up, sleep cycles, heart rate and snoring, and gives a Sleep Score built mostly from duration and depth. We found no sleep debt or sleep need figure in the Withings app. More on Withings and sleep debt.
The three compared
Prices are the makers' starting prices on the day we checked, before sales. Where a maker does not sell in Australia directly, the Australian price is a major retailer's.
| Feature | Oura Ring | Apple Watch | Withings Sleep Analyzer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Oura: Ring | Apple Watch: Watch | Withings: Under-mattress mat |
| Up-front price | Oura: Ring 5 from US$399 / A$649 | Apple Watch: SE 3 from US$249 / A$399; Series 12 from US$399 / A$649 | Withings: US$199.95 (sold in the US as Withings Sleep); A$219 at JB Hi-Fi |
| Subscription | Oura: Needed for Sleep Debt: US$5.99 a month or US$69.99 a year; A$9.99 a month | Apple Watch: None listed for sleep tracking | Withings: Optional (Withings+, US$9.95 a month); sleep data is free |
| Battery | Oura: Up to 6 to 9 days | Apple Watch: Up to 18 hours (SE 3), 24 hours (Series 12) | Withings: None: plugs into the wall |
| Shows a sleep debt? | Oura: Yes: Sleep Debt and Sleep Need, for members | Apple Watch: No: Sleep Score and a sleep goal | Withings: No: Sleep Score |
| Suits | Oura: People who want the debt figure without doing the sums, and will pay monthly for it | Apple Watch: iPhone users who want a watch in the day too, and no subscription | Withings: People who will not wear anything to bed, or forget to charge things |
| Maker's page | Oura: ouraring.com (opens in a new tab) ↗ | Apple Watch: apple.com (opens in a new tab) ↗ | Withings: withings.com (opens in a new tab) ↗ |
We don't earn anything from these links. They go straight to the manufacturer, with no affiliate tag.
Putting a tracker's hours into the calculator
The calculator takes seven nights of hours slept and a sleep need, and adds up the gap. A tracker gives you the seven nights. Four steps:
- Open the last seven nights in the tracker's app and read time asleep for each, not time in bed. The difference is often half an hour or more, and the whole of it is debt the calculator would otherwise miss.
- Round each night to the nearest half hour. The sliders move in half-hour steps, and the tracker's own figure is not more precise than that.
- Pick your sleep need. If you have no better figure, eight hours is the common working number for adults. If you wear an Oura ring, its Sleep Need is a reasonable starting point.
- Read the result as a pattern, not a reading. A tracker that counts some quiet wakefulness as sleep will make the debt look slightly smaller than it is.
If you have an Oura ring, its Sleep Debt and the calculator will rarely agree exactly. Oura looks back two weeks and weights recent nights more; the calculator looks back seven nights and weights them equally. Both are reasonable ways to draw the line.
How to choose
Start with whether you will wear it. A tracker you take off is a tracker that records nothing, and the commonest failure is a watch left on the charger at bedtime. If you do not want anything on you at night, the Withings mat is the only one of the three that asks nothing of you once it is under the mattress.
Then whether you want the debt worked out for you. Only Oura shows a sleep debt figure, and only with a membership. Over two years the membership adds about US$140 to the price of the ring, so it is worth deciding whether the figure is worth that when the calculator does the same subtraction free.
Then what you already own. An Apple Watch needs an iPhone. If you already wear one in the day, turning on sleep tracking costs nothing but a charging habit: Apple suggests at least 30% battery before bed.
And then be honest about what you want it for. If the aim is to notice that you are short of sleep, a week of the calculator will tell you that. A tracker earns its place when you want to see the pattern over months, or when you know you will not keep a diary. It will not make the nights longer on its own.
If you sleep enough and still wake unrefreshed, or you snore heavily, or someone has seen you stop breathing in your sleep, that is a question for a doctor rather than a device. Some trackers now offer sleep apnoea notifications; they are not a diagnosis, and this page does not cover them.
Common questions
Can a sleep tracker measure sleep debt? Not directly. A tracker estimates how long you slept each night, and a sleep debt figure is that total subtracted from a sleep need and added up over days. Oura does the subtraction for you; Apple Watch and Withings show the nightly hours and leave the arithmetic to you.
Is there a sleep debt app? Oura shows a Sleep Debt figure in its app, for members with a Gen3 ring or later, calculated over the past two weeks against a sleep need it learns from your own nights. Apple Health and the Withings app show nightly sleep and a Sleep Score but no debt figure, so the calculator here does that part.
How accurate are sleep trackers? For total sleep time they are reasonable, and that is the number sleep debt depends on. Sleep stages are weaker: a consumer tracker estimates them from movement and heart rate, where a sleep lab reads brain activity, and studies against lab recordings find the stage estimates much less reliable than the totals.
Do I need a tracker to work out my sleep debt? No. A week of honest bedtimes and wake times, minus the time it took to fall asleep, is enough for the calculator. A tracker saves the remembering, and is usually better than memory at the time-asleep part.
Sources
Checked on 2026-11-15. Prices and features change; the makers' own pages are the current word.
- Oura: Sleep Debt (help centre), Membership, What to know when buying an Oura Ring; Australian membership price as reported by FutureFive at the Ring 5's Australian launch.
- Apple: Track your sleep on Apple Watch, Apple Watch prices (US), (Australia), battery life.
- Withings: Sleep Analyzer, What is the Sleep Score?; Australian price from JB Hi-Fi.
- Chinoy ED et al., "Performance of seven consumer sleep-tracking devices compared with polysomnography", Sleep 2021;44(5):zsaa291.
General information, not medical advice: see the terms. We have not tested these devices ourselves; everything here comes from the makers' published information and the research above.